1. Function definition and syntax
1. FIND_IN_SET function
grammar：FIND_IN_SET(str, strlist)
Function: Find the exact matched substring (str) in a comma-separated string list (strlist) and return its position (starting from 1). If not found, return 0.
Core features：
- Only comma-separated lists (such as "apple, banana, orange") are supported.
- Requires that the substring is an independent element in the list (such as FIND_IN_SET("apple", "apple,juice") returns 1, but FIND_IN_SET("app", "apple") returns 0).
- case sensitive.
2. INSTR function
grammar：INSTR(str, substr)
Function: Find the first occurrence position of the substring (substr) in the string (str) (starting from 1), and return 0 if not found.
Core features：
Supports arbitrary string search, without relying on separators. Matching is a continuous fragment of the substring (such as INSTR("apple", "app") returns 1). case sensitive.
2. Comparison of essential differences
| Contrast dimensions | FIND_IN_SET | INSTR |
|---|---|---|
| Data structure requirements | Comma-separated list | No special format requirements |
| Matching rules | Exactly match independent elements in the list | Fuzzy match any continuous substring |
| Performance impact | Need to traverse list elements, large strings are less efficient | Usually more efficient, but depends on index and string length |
| Use scenarios | Multi-value field query (such as labels, classification lists) | Universal substring search (such as logs, long text) |
| Return value logic | Element position (starting from 1) or 0 | The start position of the substring or 0 |
3. Actual scenario case analysis
Scenario 1: Query data containing specific tags
- Suppose there is a field tags in the table articles that store comma-separated tags (such as "mysql, database, optimization").
- Requirements: Find articles containing the tag "mysql".
Correct usage:
SELECT * FROM articles WHERE FIND_IN_SET('mysql', tags) > 0;Result: Exactly match independent label elements to avoid misjudgment (such as "mysql-server" will not be matched).
Error usage:
SELECT * FROM articles WHERE INSTR(tags, 'mysql') > 0;
Problem: It may match non-independent elements (such as "mysql" in "mysql-server", resulting in inaccurate results.
Scene 2: Search for keywords in logs
Suppose there is a field message in the table logs, which stores the log text (such as "Error: Connection timeout").
need: Find logs containing the keyword "timeout".
Correct usage:
SELECT * FROM logs WHERE INSTR(message, 'timeout') > 0;
Result: Quickly locate substrings regardless of their context format.
Error usage:
SELECT * FROM logs WHERE FIND_IN_SET('timeout', message) > 0;Problem: FIND_IN_SET requires a comma-separated list. If the message is not a comma-separated structure, the query will be invalid.
4. Performance and design suggestions
1. Performance comparison
- FIND_IN_SET requires splitting and traversing comma-separated lists, with a time complexity of O(n), and is not suitable for ultra-long strings.
- INSTR usually uses optimized string search algorithms (such as Boyer-Moore), which are more efficient, but may still scan full tables due to no indexing.
2. Design suggestions
- Avoid using commas to separate storage of multi-value fields: It is recommended to use association tables (such as article_tags) to achieve many-to-many relationships to improve query efficiency and standardization.
- Select the function reasonably:
- If comma-separated fields must be used, use FIND_IN_SET first to ensure exact matches.
- For unstructured text search, select INSTR or LIKE.
- Consider full-text index: For long text fields for high-frequency searches, it is recommended to use MySQL's full-text index (FULLTEXT) to improve performance.
5. Summary
The essential difference between FIND_IN_SET and INSTR lies in the dependency and matching rules of data structures:
FIND_IN_SET is designed for comma-separated lists, emphasizing the independence of elements.
INSTR is a common substring search tool that does not depend on a specific format.
This is the article about the analysis of the usage and parsing of FIND_IN_SET function and INSTR function in MySQL. For more related contents of mysql FIND_IN_SET function and INSTR function, please search for my previous articles or continue browsing the related articles below. I hope everyone will support me in the future!